LeafGuard and LeafFilter stand out as two leading gutter guard companies on the available market, both with its unique advantages and potential drawbacks. To assist homeowners in selecting the most suitable option, we have crafted a detailed comparison guide. This guide evaluates both companies across various critical aspects such as advantages, disadvantages, warranties, customer feedback, and product details. Our objective is to equip you with the necessary information to make a well-informed choice regarding which product best meets your requirements.
Top pick
- Free estimate
- Transferable lifetime warranty
- Best curb appeal
Top pick
- Free estimate
- Transferable lifetime warranty
- Best for durability
Best alternative
- Free estimate
- Quickest replies
- Matches you with the best local contractors
LeafFilter vs LeafGuard: Essential Insights
LeafFilter and LeafGuard emerge as two of the gutter guard sector’s most distinguished brands. The primary distinction lies in their structural designs. LeafGuard operates on a reverse curve or surface tension model that necessitates replacing your present gutters. Conversely, LeafFilter employs a micro-mesh screen designed to overlay your existing gutter system. Despite their differing methodologies, both brands are renowned for their high-quality offerings, robust services, and fair pricing. Below is a concise overview of both companies:
| Insights | LeafFilter | LeafGuard |
|---|---|---|
| Our rating | 4.6 out of 5 | 4.3 out of 5 |
| BBB rating | A+ | A+ |
| Year founded | 2005 | 1993 |
| Guard type | Stainless steel micro-mesh | Aluminum reverse curve |
| Warranty type | Limited lifetime warranty | Limited lifetime warranty |
| Price per foot | $15–$45 | $10–$35 |
| Free Quote | Yes | Yes |
LeafFilter Review
LeafFilter’s gutter protection features a 275-micron stainless steel mesh, which is secured to existing gutters with a durable uPVC frame. This frame is affixed directly to the fascia board using structural hangers, eliminating the need to disturb or potentially harm the roof shingles—a common issue with many gutter guard installations. The design of LeafFilter minimizes the risk of roof damage by employing a hanger system that bypasses this concern. These hangers not only provide stability to the frame but also ensure the mesh is positioned effectively, allowing debris to fall to the ground while water flows into the gutters. The support from the frame means there’s no extra pressure on the gutters, preventing misalignment and leaks. The mesh integrates seamlessly into the gutters, making it unnoticeable from the ground.
If the existing gutters are in a stable condition and securely attached to the house, opting for LeafFilter can be more economical initially.
LeafFilter
4.6 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Specification Details
- Micro-mesh Type: Enhanced micro-filtration
- Materials: Aluminum, stainless steel, and uPVC Steel micro-mesh
- Available Sizes: 4, 5, 6, or 7-inch options
- Warranty Duration: Lifetime, transferable coverage
What We Like
LeafFilter presents a gutter protection system comprising a micro-mesh composed of three steel pieces design that utilizes surface tension to guide water through the gutters while effectively pushing debris away. The steel construction ensures resistance to warping caused by extreme temperature fluctuations. LeafFilter strategically positions the guard flush with your roof, reducing the need for frequent maintenance and minimizing visibility from ground level. Additionally, LeafFilter offers a range of colors, such as off-white and beige, allowing you to seamlessly match your home’s exterior color scheme.
Other Services
- Installation of new gutters
- Cleaning of gutters
- Sealing and repairing gutters
What We Dislike
Several reviews from LeafFilter customers have highlighted assertive sales approaches and elevated initial cost estimates. Additionally, feedback has been received regarding ice accumulation on the gutter guard during cold weather and instances of heavy rain, where debris could potentially cover the screen, impeding the smooth flow of water into the gutters.
Homeowners Sentiments
We examined the latest 100 Google Reviews for LeafFilter’s Aurora, Colorado branch. Some of these reviews expressed concerns about the company’s professionalism and punctuality. Numerous homeowners mentioned the need for multiple phone calls to ensure services were scheduled on the correct date. Despite these criticisms, LeafFilter demonstrated responsiveness to each review.
While many reviews commended the quality of LeafFilter’s gutter guards, some homeowners pointed out that these guards may not be optimal for severe winter conditions. On The Leaflet, the company’s blog, LeafFilter recommends homeowners to proactively implement precautionary measures against ice dams. Contrary to the advertised claim of never needing cleaning again, homeowners with LeafFilter’s gutter guards still find it necessary to perform gutter cleaning every one to two years..
LeafGuard Review
For homeowners requiring both new gutters and a protective cover, LeafGuard presents a robust solution. This integrated system combines a sleek, aluminum gutter with a built-in hood filter designed to allow only water through. Utilizing liquid adhesion technology, water clings to the reverse curve of the hood, directing it into the gutter while leaves and debris are left out.
LeafGuard serves a dual purpose, offering both a new gutter system and protection against debris. To ensure durability and aesthetic appeal, the entire unit is finished with ScratchGuard® paint, resistant to weathering and wear. Professional installation of LeafGuard involves on-site custom fitting of the gutters using a roll-forming process with heavy-duty aluminum, resulting in a seamless design tailored to each roofline. Its larger gutters and downspouts are engineered to manage up to 32 inches of rain per hour, significantly reducing the risk of overflow.
However, there are some considerations with LeafGuard. Primarily, it is more costly upfront compared to other gutter protection options, but this expense includes the cost of new gutters, which can make the overall cost comparable when new gutters are needed. A potential drawback is the risk of water freezing and forming ice dams due to the solid surface design, a challenge common to all gutter covers. Cleaning LeafGuard gutters, while occasionally necessary, can be more complex due to their unique reverse-curve design.
Overall, LeafGuard is an excellent investment for those in need of gutter upgrades, enhancing water management capabilities and minimizing the hassle of clogs and debris. The initial higher investment is offset by its dual functionality and long-term benefits.
LeafGuard
4.3 ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Specification Details
- Category: Curved Reversal
- Composition: Aluminum
- Available Sizes: 5/6-inch variations
- Duration of Warranty: Lifetime, transferable coverage
What We Like
For homeowners seeking innovative gutter solutions with integrated clog protection, LeafGuard stands as an excellent choice. Its reverse-curve design showcases a robust, one-piece construction, serving as a durable replacement for your current gutter system. Crafted from aluminum, this material exhibits resilience against warping and cracking, ensuring a longer lifespan compared to various do-it-yourself gutter guards.
During professional installation, LeafGuard tailors the extent of each gutter segment to achieve a seamless fit. The system boasts a finish resistant to scratches and provides a diverse color selection, offering options in a dozen or more shades to suit your preferences.
What We Dislike
LeafGuard mandates a complete replacement of the current gutter setup you have. The reverse-curve designs may be prone to permitting small debris, like shingle grit, to enter the gutters. Additionally, there is a possibility of noticeable debris buildup along the gutter guard curvature. Intense downpours could also result in water overflowing onto your home’s the exterior cladding.
Homeowners Sentiments
We conducted a review analysis encompassing 100 customer feedbacks from review websites like Trustpilot as well as BBB. Positive testimonials highlighted the expertise of the sales team, the cleanliness and courtesy during installation, and the commendable product quality. On the flip side, dissatisfied customers cited assertive sales strategies, elevated pricing, and identified restrictions within the lifetime warranty.
LeafFilter vs LeafGuard Gutters
LeafGuard and LeafFilter are both reputable providers in the gutter guard industry, offering systems designed to protect homes from debris accumulation. LeafGuard features an aluminum, one-piece system with a reverse-curve design, while LeafFilter provides a three-piece, stainless steel micro-mesh setup.
LeafGuard’s gutter guard is bolstered every two feet with concealed hangers and is capable of managing up to 32 inches of rain per hour. It also boasts downspouts that are 30% larger than typical ones, enhancing its ability to handle large volumes of water during heavy rainfalls. Although both brands design their guards to integrate smoothly with your roofline, LeafGuard’s appearance may be more prominent compared to the less intrusive design of LeafFilter.
LeafFilter vs LeafGuard Cost
Pricing details are not directly available online for either company, reflecting common practice in the gutter installation industry. Prospective customers can receive a quote after a home evaluation, which includes gutter measurement. The cost generally falls within the $900 to $2,000 range for gutter guard installations.
LeafFilter vs LeafGuard Specifications
Both LeafFilter and LeafGuard offer gutter guard systems designed to shield your home from various forms of debris like sticks and leaves. However, LeafFilter’s micro-mesh technology proves to be more effective at trapping smaller debris, such as pine needles. Below are the detailed specifications for the gutter guards provided by each company.
LeafGuard
Offers a sturdy aluminum gutter guard with a unique reverse-curve design, capable of handling significant rainfall. Its systems are custom-fitted to each home, supported by hidden hangers spaced two feet apart, and finished with a ScratchGuard® paint to resist wear and tear.
LeafFilter
Utilizes a 275-micron, surgical-grade, stainless steel micro-mesh that prevents rust and erosion, effectively blocking tiny debris. The frames are made from durable uPVC, ensuring longevity and alignment with the roof’s angle, secured with hidden hangers for aesthetic appeal.
LeafFilter vs LeafGuard Installation Process:
LeafGuard’s installation begins with a home visit for a free estimate, followed by gutter disassembly and custom guard formation on-site. The process includes fitting patented hangers, ensuring proper gutter pitch, and attaching downspouts, concluding with a cleanup of the premises.
LeafFilter also offers a similar installation service, starting with gutter inspection and followed by cleaning, potential gutter replacement, and guard installation, ensuring correct gutter alignment and pitch before finishing up.
LeafFilter vs LeafGuard Maintenance and Cleaning:
Annual checks are recommended for gutter guards to ensure their efficiency, although LeafGuard and LeafFilter systems reduce the need for frequent cleaning. LeafGuard may require snow removal to prevent ice dam formation, while LeafFilter might need debris removal after heavy rainfalls. Both systems aim to minimize maintenance but may require attention after severe weather conditions.
LeafFilter vs. LeafGuard Warranty
LeafFilter and LeafGuard both offer warranties to back their gutter guard systems, though the specifics and coverage of these warranties differ.
LeafGuard’s warranty is a transferable lifetime guarantee covering the gutter and its accessories. Should the LeafGuard system suffer from blistering, flaking, chipping, cracking, peeling, rotting, rusting, or other structural damages due to manufacturing defects or normal wear and tear, the company commits to repairing, replacing, or cleaning the affected parts. This warranty will only apply if the system was installed according to LeafGuard’s standards and the recommended cleaning practices have been maintained.
On the other hand, LeafFilter also provides a lifetime transferable warranty, but with notable restrictions. This warranty does not extend to any damage to the gutters, fascia boards, roof substrate, or any surfaces affected by the installation of the gutter guards. Additionally, it does not cover incidental damages resulting from ice dams or ice flows. The warranty may be invalidated if the LeafFilter system is damaged due to structural changes to the house, such as roof modifications, the influence of nearby trees or vegetation, or other uncontrollable natural events like storms. Any modifications or alterations made to the guards after installation could also result in the voiding of the warranty.
The transferable nature of both warranties enhances the value of your home by ensuring that the gutter guard protection is guaranteed for subsequent owners.
LeafFilter vs Leafguard: which to choose?
LeafFilter presents a gutter guard solution that not only functions efficiently but also enhances the visual appeal of your home, making it an attractive option for homeowners who prioritize curb appeal. Due to its design, which captures a significant amount of debris, you might find yourself cleaning the gutters more frequently. Nonetheless, LeafFilter performs more effectively in preventing ice dams and icicles compared to LeafGuard. If your priorities lean more towards durability and long-term performance over aesthetics, then LeafGuard stands out as a reliable option. For those exploring a range of options, our comprehensive guide on the best gutter guards offers insights into various companies and their offerings to help you find the ideal solution for your home.
How We Chose The Best Gutter Guard Providers
Our team engaged in a thorough study and evaluation of numerous gutter guard products and their manufacturers, crafting an all-encompassing review methodology. This included the creation of a scoring metric that mirrors the priorities of homeowners. We evaluated each supplier based on critical factors such as the design and aesthetic appeal of their gutter guards, the breadth of services offered, customer service and engagement, the quote acquisition process, warranty terms, and payment options available.
Additionally, we investigated each company’s standing by consulting neutral, external entities like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) and Google My Business profiles.